- Written by Nick Breeze Nick Breeze
- Published: 08 October 2016 08 October 2016
Setting the scene for Malbec
The tasting was set up in the basement of Casa Malevo in Connaught Street London, a place famous for exceedingly high quality steak, a frequent food pairing for the malbec grape we were due to taste.
Young winemaker, Rodrigo Zamorano, himself confessed to not being impressed with malbec when he first started tasting it in Chile and Argentina (despite spending a long time touring French regions, he actually never visited Cahors). So to be sat in London exhibiting a range of wines that have inspired him as well as those he has created, signals quite a volt face.
What made this tasting so interesting was that the winemaker was presenting his own wines placed within the context of, not only the wines that have inspired his own endeavours, but those that are arguably his greatest competition.
A grape of 3 nations?
Argentina seems to have made a home for malbec in the minds of the consumer but really its roots are much deeper in Cahors, SW France, and also still, marginally, as one of the grapes still used in Bordeaux blending.
Although France is where malbec has been mostly found over the centuries, when I asked Rodrigo how long the grape variety has been growing in Chile he says, “A long time, over 200 years! We have plants we are working with that are 80 years old.”
When I voiced surprise, having expected this to be an experiment growing out of the Argentine success with the grape, he then cautiously (but with a sense of humour) says that it was very likely malbec arrived in Chile first, not Argentina. That certainly adds a little more perspective than I had bargained for!
Chilean malbec in context:
I must admit that in the past I have been a bit disappointed with malbec’s we’ve selected in restaurants, so this did feel like a make or break evening. Most of my judgement was based on wines from Mendoza so this was a good opportunity to place the grape in some sort of regional context
This tasting has changed my view (see notes below), meaning I am now far from giving up on malbec.
I asked if Rodrigo could somehow place Chilean malbec in relation to Cahors and Argentina, to which he replied:
“We have a climate more similar to what they have in Cahors. The thing is that you really have to have the soil. That is more difficult. That’s why we find that we have this specific soil that is more similar to what you have in Cahors. We take profit of this irony to make this sharp and very clean malbec but also the climate is very gentle and helps to give us [our own] style of wine. So if you ask me to describe malbec in Chile then I would say we are more close to Cahors than to Argentina.”
Rodrigo talked at length about how the climate and soils effected the typicity of the wines in ways he hadn’t expected. I asked if he could give us a single line on each of the three regions we tasted:
Argentina: Floral, fruity, ready to drink malbec
Cahors: More complexity, sharp, time helps it a lot in terms of the quality of the wine
Chile: Fruit, also floral and a little bit sharper. It’s ready to drink too.
Wines tasted with the meal:
Achaval Ferrer Finca Mirador - 2013, Mendoza
Lovely dark fruit, attractive spice and even hints of dark chocolate. Lots of life in the mouth, silk tannin, so an obvious choice for the fine steak.
Chateau Du Cédre Le Grand Cédre - 2012, Cahors
Dark inky appearance with layers of dark fruit aromas. Gorgeously rich ripe dark fruit in the mouth and lovely tannin for the food. Different from the first wine in the depth and intensity of the flavour. Longer length. Great wine!
Caliterra Tributo Malbec - 2014, Colchagua
Dark in colour, lovely hint of rose aromas as well as strawberry, blackcurrant, redcurrant. Young dry tannins, richness in flavour with the red and blackcurrant. Can drink now but
Chateau les Croisille Divin - 2011, Cahors
Dark berry fruit aroma, different from the others in that there is more earthiness, peppery perhaps. Has a more Bordeaux taste to it. Unctuous and begging for big meat dishes, roasted veg. Interesting as it is a marked difference from the above wines.
Alto las Hormigas Gualtallary, 2013 - Uco Valley Mendoza
Not so interesting to me as the preceding wines. Lighter in colour, more mineral and red fruit, sweeter tannins.
Zorzal Eggo - 2012, Uco Valley, Mendoza
Very attractive aromas of violets, different with a more plummy character. Good gripping tannin, perfect for heavier meat dishes. Decent length - very enjoyable wine.
Caliterra Tributo Pétreo 20th Anniversary Malbec - 2014, Colchagua
Probably my joint favourite wine of the evening, (along with the Chateau de Cedre) - lovely fresh mixed berry fruit taste, silk tannins and a pleasurably long meandering taste.
A taste for the sustainability of wine
This was a refreshing and fun tasting that has made me less sceptical of malbec than I might otherwise be. I have friends who routinely associate steak with Argentinian malbec and although I am not trying to dissuade anyone from drinking the fine wines of Mendoza and elsewhere, having some perspective on this grape is highly valuable and may increase the appreciation of the overall gastronomic experience.